Tuesday 29 March 2016

The Forgotten and the Fantastical 2 - a storming follow up

I've been hopeless recently about writing about books on here, because I was feeling too much pressure to write lots, so things were backing up. So instead I'm religiously logging each one on Goodreads (actually am a tiny bit behind there too) but wanted chance for a longer rave about this one. You know I'm involved with Mother's Milk Books, insofar as I help out behind the scenes a little when I can, and Teika is a dear friend, but it doesn't change what I think about the books (and I'd certainly not rave about something I didn't find rave-worthy)

The second volume of "The Forgotten and The Fantastical", published earlier this month, opens with a gloriously strong first three stories.

Rebecca Ann Smith's Rumpelstiltskin is such a creative take on the story, with an inspiring writing of the process of drawing a creative output from deep inside the self, at a horrible cost. The way she deals with the promising of the firstborn to Rumpelstiltskin, and its aftermath, has made me cry on each of several rereads. Then the wonderful Hansel's Trouble from Lindsey Watkins - I loved her story in last year's anthology, but loved this one even more. It puts the children's story into a real context, and speaks of the truth for those who suffer young: there is nothing as simple as an escape to ever-after happiness.
Last in these first three is Ana Salote's Grimm Reality, a more whimsical story but no less absorbing for that. Again, I'm a raving fan of Ana's writing, and this shows again her ability to capture magic even in the unpromising setting of Elephant and Castle.

I wanted to talk about these first three pieces in particular because they're such a strong start, and this matters to me in an anthology. I think Teika applied real editorial skill in how she has ordered the pieces, so there's a balance, and some shifting of mood. It also gave the chance for a gap before the other Rumpelstiltskin story, which I also found entrancing. Perhaps I'm biassed towards stories that capture the feeling between a mother and her baby; perhaps I like to tease myself with trauma. But this second Rumpelstiltskin, called Trash into cash (Becky Tipper) was modern, original, and deeply felt.
The other piece I want to mention by name was Nathan Ramsden's Icarus. I'd looked forward to it because his two stories in the last anthology were so original, and elegantly written. This one was, too - to my mind he's one of those writers who will have people saying one day "I knew him when he was starting out". There's just something about the confidence of tone, and the complete mastery of the whole story, that makes a reader feel in safe hands, willing to go wherever they are taken. 

Those were my top five, as it were, but there were thirteen other pieces too, all very readable, and with many other high points. As with any anthology, a few appealed to me less, and one or two were less skilled in execution, but much of this is personal taste. It's a meatier book than last year's, and an even higher standard in general. It's also given me some writing ideas: there were a few pieces in there I wished I'd written.

And, as ever, a beautiful book to look at and hold - Emma Howitt's pictures at the start of each story add atmosphere perfectly, without shouting for attention, but repaying it when they get it. I'm looking forward to filling my shelf with a row of these from year after year...

Mother's Milk Books


8 comments:

  1. I managed to get to the launch of this and loved hearing some of the writers read from their stories. I'm really looking forward to finding the time to settle down with the whole book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's well worth it, Anne - I'm afraid I'm a terrible guzzler of short stories and even poems, and can't resist storming through a whole volume in one or two sittings, though people tell me there's a lot to be said for reading slowly...

      Delete
  2. I haven't finished all the stories yet so can't pick a favourite. They are great for reading singly on short journeys. I agree about Nathan, definitely one to watch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You see, Ana, you're one of those who has the discipline to read singly! I'm terrible at the moment for wasting brain space by monkeying around on my phone if I think I'll only have a short gap, not making the most of all that good potential reading time.

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the lovely review, Helen. Though of course I can't pick a favourite, because I love them all. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It would be a shocker if you came on here and said phew, I really regretted a couple of those, thank goodness no one's picked up the howlers yet...

      Delete
  4. Thank you for the mention. There are so many lovely stories in there. I sympathise about the pressure to catch up on these things - I joined goodreads a while back but keeping up with it seems like an impossible task from a fairy tale, so I have given up (until a little man appears and offers to write all my reviews for me!...)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. my pleasure, Becky - I really liked your story. I was so sure goodreads was the key because you can write just one line, or just give an enigmatic unexplained rating, but I'm behind even on that. Some of it is embarrassment at admitting I've been reading children's books - I think it's time for me to write another post on "book shame".

      Delete